Note: Due to supply issues with COVID19, prices may change without notice.
Scones: $1.99 each
Orange, Lemon, or Almond: We candy orange peels, lemon peels, and sliced almonds for added flavoring. The sugar used to candy the peel is mixed into the scone and sprinkled atop. We additionally use a small amount of Watkins Jr. flavored extract to enhance the flavor. This process is used for a great tasting, naturally flavored product!
Herb Roasted Sweet Potato: Roasted sweet potatoes with garlic, thyme, rosemary, as well as a bit of salt, pepper and olive oil, mixed into our classic scone mix. A savory treat you're sure to enjoy!
Cookies: $2.49 each
Candied Walnut and Chocolate Chip Cookie: We create candied walnuts using white and brown sugar with Watkins pure ground cinnamon. Slow roasting makes a spicy, sweet treat to complement a traditional Tollhouse chocolate chip cookie.
Drunken Rum Raisin and Oatmeal Cookie: Our raisins are soaked in a bit of rum so they will be ready for baking, then mixed with oatmeal and flavored with Watkins organic cinnamon. This always makes a tasty treat.
Muffins: $1.99 each
Blueberry Muffins: Fresh blueberries mixed right into our homemade batter...what more could one want?
Carrot and Zucchini Muffins: Zucchini and carrots with cinnamon, ginger and other spices make this a great treat any time of day. Best if heated (350 degrees for 5 minutes) and topped with a little bit of butter.
Baklava: $2.99 each
Have you ever had baklava that hardly contained any nuts and was very dry? Well, thankfully here at Cutie Pies that is unheard of! Each batch has a pound of walnuts, a pound of pecans and three cups of honey! Add Watkins organic cinnamon, cinnamon sticks, cloves and a touch of cardamom and you have a tasty treat.
Banana Bread: $2.99 per loaf
Bananas, walnuts and pecans. Heated with a little butter is always best. (We do carry this product without nuts from time to time. If interested, call ahead to see if it's in stock. If not, we can gladly get some ready for you!)
Cannoli: $2.99 each
Coated with chocolate spread and chocolate sprinkles then filled with Cutie Pies’ pastry cream. A classic!
Biscotti: $1.25 each
Our chocolate and vanilla biscotti is made on site. We use Watkins vanilla for the vanilla and Hershey’s cocoa for the chocolate…simple and delicious. A great pair for your morning coffee!
Brownie: $1.75 each
Our brownies aren't just your average brownie. They are baked exactly like cookies! Baked to perfection with an extra fudge-like center.
Angel Food Cake: $1.99 per slice/ $17.99 whole (10 slices)
Our almond, vanilla and chocolate angel food cakes are served with one of our in-house ‘signature sauces: butterscotch, caramel or chocolate.
Pound Cake: $2.99 per slice/ $27.99 whole (10 slices)
Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon Glaze – Our homemade lemon pound cake is flavored with Watkins lemon extract and covered in a simple confectionery sugar and lemon juice glaze. Lemony goodness in every bite!
Chocolate Pound Cake with Raspberry Jam and Chocolate Ganache – Hershey’s cocoa is used to create a delicious classic chocolate pound cake. Covered in seedless raspberry jam and chocolate ganache will keep the chocolate lover satisfied….at least for a little while!
Sometimes the simplest things in life are the best. Flour, water, salt and yeast makes a great tasting Italian bread.
Plain: $2.99 per loaf
Garlic and Rosemary: $3.99 per loaf
Thyme and Parmesan: $3.99 per loaf
Chess Pie: $2.49 mini / $17.99 whole
Now talk about an old southern pie! Eggs, sugar and butter make this custard pie one of our sweetest!
Lemon Chess Pie: $2.75 mini / $18.99 whole
Our number one selling custard pie! Take the chess pie and add some lemon juice and lemon zest and you have an award winner.
Pecan Pie: $3.29 mini / $22.99 whole
Is there a pie more southern than pecan? Let the dessert wars begin!!!
Key Lime Pie: $2.99 mini/ $15 whole
Herb Roasted Sweet Potato: $2.99 mini
Blueberry: $2.99 mini / $20.99 whole
Our number one selling fruit pie! Heat and have with some vanilla ice cream and be in heaven…at least until the last bite!
Cherry: $3.29 mini / $20.99 whole
An American classic. We use a mix of sweet cherries with a hint of fresh spearmint to brighten the flavor.
Peach Cobbler: $3.29 mini / $20.99 whole
We use a classic peach pie recipe with an added streusel crumble topping instead of our traditional lattice crust.
Apple: $3.29 mini / $20.99 whole
Fresh Gala apples with Watkins organic cinnamon and Cutie Pies' flakey crust. Makes one patriotic just thinking about it!
We have a variety of ice creams to meet your needs. Have with a slice of cake or one of our mini pies today!
Flavors: Butter Pecan, Cappuccino Crunch, Lemon Sorbet, Caramel Cheesecake, Chocolate, Vanilla, Black Cherry, and Peach
Single Scoop: $2.99
Double Scoop: $5.75
Don't Be Blue: $5.00
Scoop with mini blueberry pie
Add scoop to any other mini pie: $2.75
Strawberry Shortcake: $2.75 per slice
Our strawberry shortcake has been a hit while we’ve been able to keep it in stock. In fact, it’s been so popular, we’re going to keep it on our menu as long as we can do so affordably!
Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake: $2.75 per slice
Our vanilla angel food cake has been a hit with our strawberry shortcake, but we thought we could make it even better! We now carry our strawberry shortcake on our chocolate angel food cake!
We have officially entered the world of macarons! Prepare for more flavors to come soon!
Salted Caramel Macarons: $1.75 each
Lemon Macarons: $1.75 each
Oreo Macarons: $1.75 each
Key Lime Macarons: $1.75 each